With all the types and sizes of screens that now exist on our smartphones and computers, the topic of image optimization of a website has become quite complicated. In my last article I explained you how you could compress your images to reduce their weight while keeping a beautiful quality (you will also find a detailed comparison and test of the best WP image optimization plugin here). But even if your images have been well compressed, this does not mean that the browser displays the right image according to the type and size of the screen (understand that it is possible that the browser loads an image of 1500X1000 and actually displays it in 900X600… this is not optimal because the loaded image is much heavier than it should be).
In this article I will focus on the case of images in the WordPress CMS. But know that most of the things I will talk about below are valid for any website that displays different images depending on the size and type of screen (which is really important in 2019 😉 ).
What happens when you upload an image in the WordPress admin
When you add an image to the Media Library, WordPress will automatically create multiple copies of that image with different dimensions. Besides, you may have noticed that when you insert a media in an article, you can choose by default between 4 image sizes:
- Full size : the original dimensions of the image you uploaded
- Large : the default image has a maximum width of 1024px or a maximum height of 1024px (this can be changed in the media settings)
- Medium : the default image has a maximum width of 300px or a maximum height of 300px
- Thumbnail : the default image has a maximum width of 150px and a maximum height of 150px
Also note that since wordpress 4.4, a 5th image size between large and medium is automatically created with a width of 768px (no max height). So you see that by default, wordpress already creates 5 images on your server each time you upload media to your library.
Without going into details, you should also know that wordpress theme developers also have the ability to add different image sizes that may be necessary for a specific design. So it is quite possible that you have more than 5 images created each time (for example, for the theme I created for our novo-monde travel blog, I added an extra size so that each time I put an image in the library, it is actually 6 images that are created).
Since version 5.3 of WordPress it is no longer 5 images but 8 that are created each time you add an image to your media library. For more details, I wrote a complete article about this update
But why does wordpress create copies of images of different sizes?
Responsive images: Different images depending on the size and type of screen
Images in WordPress before version 4.4
Basically, wordpress created these different image sizes so that you could simply choose whether you wanted to insert a larger or smaller image into your web pages. When you added media to your page, wordpresse simply added an html image tag as follows:
<img src="http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/large-size-img-1024x700.jpg" alt="large size image alt">
or something like that :
<img src="http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/medium-size-img-300x200.jpg" alt="medium size image alt">
The concrete case of a responsive website
But with the arrival of responsive websites (which adapt to screen size) and the emergence of mobile phones, this way of inserting images was no longer appropriate. A smarter way to insert images had to be found so that the browser could choose the most appropriate copy of the image for the size and type of screen.
To better represent all this, let’s take the classic example of an image aligned on the left on a site with a design that adapts to the size of the screens (responsive) as on our own blog. Here is how an image aligned on the left behaves on novo-monde:
You can see that there are 3 scenarios and that depending on the width of the screen, the image behaves differently:
- if the width is greater than 861px, the image is 363px wide
- if the width is between 481px and 861px, the image is 50% of the width
- if the width is less than 481px, the image is 100% of the width
This kind of CSS rule is called “media queries”and is the basis of any good adaptive website.
It’s all very nice but the idea now is to tell the browser to choose among all the different sizes available to us (6 in the case of our blog novo-monde), the image that has the most suitable dimensions according to the size and type of screen… So understand that if you look at the site on a mobile phone, you don’t want it to load the image in its original size 🙂 because the image would be much too heavy for the quality at which it would be displayed (and it would not be good for your loading speed and SEO)
The arrival of srcset and sizes attributes
To solve this problem, the developers introduced 2 new attributes to the image tag which are srcset and sizes. These attributes were introduced in wordpress from version 4.4 and now when you add an image to an article, the image tag is a little more complicated. So here’s what I get when I insert a left-aligned image on our blog:
read my post about wp 5.3<img class="alignleft" src="https://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/large-1024x723.jpg" alt="image alt" srcset="http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/grand-1024x723.jpg 1024w, http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/average-300x212.jpg 300w, http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/average-large-768x542.jpg 768w, http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/very-large-1508x1065.jpg 1508w, http://acoolblog.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/full-size.jpg 3200w" sizes="(min-width: 861px) 363px, (min-width: 481px) 50vw, 100vw" >
You can see that the image tag is much larger because both srcset and sizes attributes have been added (they are highlighted in purple). Let’s analyse together what is in these two new attributes:
- srcset : You see that the srcset attribute contains 5 urls of the same image but of different size. In addition, for each url it also contains information on the width of the image. WordPress therefore puts in the srcset attribute all the copies of an image it has at its disposal except the one of the thumbnail size. This information will allow the browser to know which image sizes are available.
- sizes : In the sizes attribute, you may notice that the numbers look strangely similar to the behavior of the left-aligned image I described above. This is because this attribute is there to describe to the browser how the image should behave. If we check at how it works:
(min-width: 861px) 363px: This means that if the width is greater than 861px, the image must be 363px wide.
(min-width: 481px) 50vw: If the width is greater than 481px (but less than 861px because of the other line), the image must have a width of 50% of the space at its disposal
100vw: In all other cases (roughly if the width is less than 481px), the image must take up 100% of the space at its disposal.
NB: You will notice that the above figures are only here as an example and have been set up specifically for our theme. The rules to define for your own site will depend on your theme and its behavior according to the different screen sizes.
If these two attributes are correctly defined in your theme, the browser will be able to determine which image is the best (among those available in the srcset) based on the width and type of screen. I will give you some examples to help you understand better:
- If you have a Retina screen (pixel density twice as high) 1300px wide, the browser knows that the image must be 363px wide. But since you have a Retina screen, the browser will need a twice as large an image and will therefore choose the medium-large version which is 768px wide.
- Imagine that you have a tablet with a 600px wide non-Retina screen. The browser knows that the image must be 50% wide (i.e. 300px) and will therefore choose the medium version available to it, which is precisely 300px wide.
How do you know if your wordpress theme has responsive images?
Now that I’ve explained all this to you, I’m sure you’re dying to know if your wordpress theme (or your website in general) has properly integrated adaptive images. If you want to check, you can for example follow these steps:
- Open an article on your site using the Chrome browser (it’s no advertising… just the browser I prefer for this kind of thing)
- Put your cursor on an image, right-click and choose “inspect”
- You should see the img tag of the image in question which should contain both srcset and sizes attributes.
- If you move your cursor over the src attribute, a small window will open telling you which version of the image is used (in the currentSrc)… this is how you can check if it is the correct version of the image that is loaded
If so, it’s already a good start… but that doesn’t mean that the srcset and sizes attributes are correctly set up. In my experience here is how wordpress works by default (i.e. if you install wordpress without any special themes, that’s how it works;) ) :
How does srcset and sizes behave by default in WordPress
Let’s assume that you have put in your media library an image that is 3200px wide and 2138px high (this is the size of the image I had chosen to test). You insert this medium size image in your article, here is the image tag that is created by wordpress (on a fresh wordpress installation with the twentyseventeen theme):
<img class="size-medium alignleft" src="http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-300x200.jpg" alt="le alte de mon image" width="300" height="200" srcset="http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-300x200.jpg 300w, http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-768x513.jpg 768w, http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-1024x684.jpg 1024w" sizes="(max-width: 300px) 100vw, 300px" >
If you insert the large size image in an article (525px wide in the twentyseventeen theme), you will get this tag :
<img class="size-large alignleft" src="http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-1024x684.jpg" alt="le alte de mon image" width="525" height="351" srcset="http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-300x200.jpg 300w, http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-768x513.jpg 768w, http://localhost/app/uploads/2018/03/DSC08456_2-1024x684.jpg 1024w" sizes="(max-width: 525px) 100vw, 525px" >
When I look at the created tags, I notice 2 main things:
- The original image (3200px wide) is not in the srcset attribute. This is because by default, wordpress applies a 1600px limit to prevent themes that were not designed to work with adaptive images from loading huge images. This limit can be removed using this function (which I use on our theme to remove the limit).
- The sizes attribute is very simplistic. It means that if the screen size is larger than the image, the width of the image must not exceed the defined size (300px or 525px). If the screen is smaller than the width of the image, the image must take the full width of the screen. We will say that this rule is well suited for designs that are not too complicated with images that take the full width of the screen up to a certain size. But for more advanced responsive sites, the sizes attribute must be modified so that the most suitable image is loaded in all cases! (if there are developers reading this, you must use this filter to modify the sizes attribute. You can also read this article which gives an excellent example of how to implement this filter).
I will give you that, for the normal user of wordpress, it may sound a bit like gibberish. But just by inspecting your image tag, you can already check if you are not using unnecessarily large (or small) versions of your images… it is already a good start.
But… I’m not a developer and my images are not responsive… what can I do??
Install a wordpress theme with responsive images
So I’ll be honest with you, I have the impression that this wordpress feature is a little ignored by theme developers. I have tried to test demos of many of the most popular themes sold on the web and none of them customize the image sizes attribute. Considering what can be done with these two attributes and that loading images larger than they are displayed slows down the loading time of web pages, I find it very strange and it’s such a pity!
Anyway, if you know of any wordpress themes that use these two attributes to their full potential, I would be happy to add them to the article 😉 (don’t hesitate to give me links in comments)
Use a specialized CDN for images
There are also specialized CDN services for images that claim to be able to serve images directly to the right dimensions. How does a CDN work for images? Instead of being served from your server, your images are distributed on a server network around the world and are served from the server closest to the user. In theory, since these servers are specialized in image management, they are also supposed to compress images (in this case, the use of a compression plugin becomes redundant) and serve them to the ideal dimensions for display on the browser (but this remains to be verified). Here are some examples of this type of CDN
- Photon : The best known of these services is certainly photon from the Jetpack wordpress plugin. Once activated, your images will automatically be placed on the photon servers and all the urls of your images will be rewritten to redirect to these servers. According to the documentation, the plugin is based on the width and height attributes of your img tags or on the size of the image container (it chooses the smallest of the two) to display images directly resized to the correct size. So even if srcset attributes and sizes are not available on your site, images should be served directly at the right size.
The negative point of photon is that all images are automatically cached without any way to empty it (so to make a modification on an image, it is necessary to create a new one in the library). In addition, if you delete an image from your media library, it will not be deleted from the photon server. And of course, you have to install a huge plugin like jetpack just for photon.
- ExactDN : ExactDN is an option of the plugin ewww image optimizer which works on the same principle as photon. Unlike Photon, ExactDN is not free and requires an API key to work. However, you can clear the cache of your images and delete them using this solution. I haven’t had time to test this solution yet but as soon as I’ll have some, I will give you a feedback. More information about ExactDN here.
- I’ve also seen other plugins like Cloudinary, Sirv… that offer essentially the same kind of services
My opinion on CDNs specialized in images
After looking at some sites that use photon or ExactDN, I get the impression that these services respect the rules defined in the srcset and sizes attributes (maybe I’m wrong but that’s my impression). So for sites that have these attributes implemented (with the default wordpress rules), I don’t think these CDNs will solve the adaptive image problem.
In my opinion, you can use this kind of service if you want your images to be served more quickly to your readers (for example, for Internet users browsing your site from remote areas of your server). But at that moment, you might as well put your whole site on a CDN and not just the images.
there too, I would love to get feedback from people who use these services regularly and who don’t necessarily have the same opinion as me 😉
The solution of the lesser evil for Mr. and Mrs. everyone
I am well aware that I have not yet given a satisfactory answer for all people who do not want (or know) to get their hands in the code to change the srcset and sizes attributes. If this is your case, here is how you should insert the images into your articles:
Always insert your images with the size (available in your theme) closest to the dimensions of the image on the large screen! For example, if you insert a left-aligned image and it is 400px wide on a large screen, choose the available image size that is closest to 400px wide. Same thing if you insert a centered image and it is 1200px wide on large screens, choose the available size closest to these 1200px.
You’re going to tell me, but why is that?
Remember the default wordpress settings for the sizes attribute. If you insert an image aligned on the left with a size of 400px wide, here is the attribute that will be created:
sizes="(max-width: 400px) 100vw, 400px"
This rule means: if the screen width is less than 400px, the image width is equal to the screen width. In all other cases, the width of the image is 400px. This rule will probably be good for mobiles (where images are usually displayed in full screen) and for large screens. It is possible that the behavior on intermediate sizes is not optimal but I think it is a lesser evil!
A plugin for WP galleries that integrates responsive images
It may sound crazy but since I’ve been using WordPress, I’ve only found one gallery plugin that correctly integrates srcset and sizes attributes (and is compatible with WordPress native galleries). This plugin is called Meow gallery and I now use it on all my sites! I was so happy to find this plugin that I even wrote a whole article about it:
Finally, I know that the subject of image dimensions in wordpress is quite ” unpleasant ” but I think it is important to understand how all this works in order to avoid loading unnecessarily large images and to optimize the loading speed of your site. Otherwise I would say that if you already have the srcset and sizes attributes in your images with their default settings (and you follow my last advice), it’s already a good start.
And above all, if anything is unclear, feel free to leave me your questions in commentary on the article 😉